Новости Донбасса
novosti.dn.ua
БЕСПЛАТНО – В App Store
скачать

How Croatia won separatism and why Ukraine is not Croatia. Part 4

How Croatia won separatism and why Ukraine is not Croatia. Part 4

In the conditions of the Russian military aggression the experience of other countries that have faced similar challenges became actual for Ukraine. In this context, they often referred to the experience of Croatia, one of few countries which managed to repel military aggression and to recapture its territory within the administrative boundaries.

This experience is especially interesting because it includes both military operations and political dialogue and peaceful reintegration. In Ukraine we decided to talk more about the military components of Croats success. The political component is less likely to say or we almost do not say about it.


Please follow the link to read the 3rd part  of the story

Conclusions for Ukraine

Upon a certain similarity of the wars in Ukraine and Serbia they are still different conflicts, so not all parallels are relevant. In Ukraine it is decided to hold up the military operation "Storm" and "Lightning" as an example, it is accepted to require to conduct similar operations without assessing the capabilities of the sides.

Many people write about similarities of situations, and we will look at the differences:

- Serb separatists opposed to Croatia with the support of Serbia which was better armed and more populated, but was not nuclear and world power.

- In the course of "Storm" and "Lightning" operations there were released the territories which do not have a direct border with Serbia, at that time the Serbian army has been removed therefrom;

- The political leadership of Croatia had not went in for a military operation on the territory adjacent to the Serbian border (Vukovar with its surroundings) although it had such plans. It is the plain here and there was a high probability that in the case of direct interference of Serbia tank battles could begin with a large number of victims;

- Effectiveness of political negotiations after which Serbia recognizes the territorial integrity of Croatia and does not interfere with peaceful reintegration;

- Presence of political will and capacity of the military operation in case of failure of negotiations. After the war, many of the generals who conducted those operations have been accused of war crimes;

- By the time of "Storm" and "Lightning" operations Serbia managed to get stuck tightly to the conflict in Bosnia that was much harder than the conflict in Croatia. The number of casualties there exceeded 100 thousand people;

- The scales of the conflict and its territory were significantly lower and smaller;

- Readiness to go for the full mobilization of all resources in a politically opportune moment. In a country with a population of about 4.5 million people, about 500 thousand (soldiers and support staff) have a veteran status. In Ukraine, nobody has openly working off variants for complete mobilization yet.

General comparisons with the operation "Storm" are more suitable for the summer campaign of 2014, when the Ukrainian Army in a short time liberated a considerable part of the occupied cities of Donbas until it has been staved already by Russian troops in Ilovaisk.

Peaceful reintegration in Croatia was a multifactorial process, and in any case it is impossible to consider the individual elements of this process from the standpoint of short-term political expediency, to separate its military component from the peaceful one, to ignore the geopolitical context and close our eyes to the problems that it has not decided yet. Although the so-called "Croatian variant" (combined reintegration)  showed its practical effectiveness, but also had negative consequences for those who implemented it.

One of the organizers of the military operations, national hero Ante Gotovina of Croatia hided for a long time from the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia countries that accused him of ethnic cleansing, namely, the expulsion of Serbs. Gotovina even has been recognized guilty, but he has managed to secure an acquittal by the appeal.

The similarity of the situation in Croatia with Ukrainian realities gives Ukraine a kind of "head start", allows us more accurately to simulate the possible solutions to the conflict, especially because its mechanisms have already been developed both by its sides and the international community. In the end, despite the obvious successes of the Croats, it is always better to learn their mistakes than to repeat them.

To summarize, the Croatian experience is a compulsion to peaceful integration with the help of military operations under the threat of full-scale war, commitment, mobilization of all resources, successful diplomacy and, primarily, self-reliance and fighting for own hands.

New service "Explain Ukraine". This is a daily mailout of five articles which were written about the situation in the Donbas by Donbas journalists and translated into English. Honest vision of people who work in the field is unbiased and fresh which is crucial in the world which is full of desinformation and propaganda. We try to share this vision in out daily mailout.  You can subscribe here.

For material : "Новости Донбасса "

NEWS DONETSK / LUGANSK ALL
20:32
How can school students and school leavers from the uncontrolled territory get Ukrainian education?
17:26
OSCE SMM records over 5,300 truce breaches in Donbas over week
13:22
Russia will never return Crimea to Ukraine – Putin
12:19
Nayev, Hug discuss security situation along contact line in Donbas – JFO press center
16:25
Moscow City Court sentences Ukrainian Sushchenko to 12 years for spying
16:21
Russia supplies cargo for military purposes to Donbas – U.S. rep to OSCE
12:00
Russian-backed militants mount 27 attacks on Ukraine army in Donbas in past day – JFO HQ
17:01
Ukraine's presidential administration believes Trump's meeting with Poroshenko should precede meeting with Putin
16:22
Donetsk regional police chief Abroskin appointed deputy head of National Police of Ukraine
21:12
Ukrainian Rada deputy Savchenko questioned in SBU about her visit to Donetsk
20:05
OSCE mission reports deterioration of security situation in Donbas
13:00
Ukraine to demand broader sanctions for those who 'nationalized' enterprises in Donbas - Poroshenko
12:16
Travelers may use passports of DPR, LPR to enter Belarus; decision on stay to be made individually - Belarusian Interior Ministry
14:20
Akhmetov's humanitarian staff reports blocking of its work in Donetsk
13:10
DPR, LPR heads demand Kyiv lift Donbas blockade, otherwise threaten to take over enterprises under Ukrainian jurisdiction
08:26
Vice News relised report from Donetsk
15:02
Lives on the Line: short documentary about situation in the Donbas region
15:02
Lawyer Feygin: Russia still refusing to let Ukrainian consul see arrested journalist Sushchenko
14:20
ICRC to repay Ukraine utilities debts for occupied Luhansk
17:17
Euronews show life on Ukraine's front line in 360-degree video
VIDEO
Vice News relised report from Donetsk
Vice News correspondent Jake Hanrahan visited Donetsk, which stay under control by "Donetsk People's Republic".
27 December, 08:26
Lives on the Line: short documentary about situation in the Donbas region
This 6-minute documentary tells the stories of civilians who have been living in an active conflict zone for over two years.
08 December, 15:02